Post

REST vs SOAP: A Brief Comparison

Understand the key differences between REST and SOAP APIs — including protocols, data formats, flexibility, and use cases. Perfect for beginners exploring web services.

REST vs SOAP: A Brief Comparison
  • REST vs SOAP – Just Fundamentals
  • SOAP: The Protocol
  • REST: The Architectural Style
  • Summary for REST vs SOAP

REST vs SOAP – Just Fundamentals

When diving into the world of web services, developers often encounter two widely-used ways to enable communication between systems: SOAP and REST.
While both serve the same ultimate goal — to enable communication between a client and a server — they do so in fundamentally different ways.

Let’s break them down to their essence. No fluff, no fanboy wars — just clean, core understanding.


SOAP: The Protocol

Transport
SOAP messages are typically sent over HTTP POST, but can also be transported using SMTP and other protocols.
Regardless of the transport, SOAP is its own protocol — independent and structured.

Why It Is a Protocol
SOAP (Simple Object Access Protocol) is called a protocol because it has a well-defined message structure.
Every SOAP message wraps its content in a strict XML-based format called the SOAP Envelope.

The Envelope contains:

  • Header (optional): for metadata like authentication, transaction control, etc.
  • Body (mandatory): contains the actual request or response — the operation and data being exchanged.

Note:
This body is not to be confused with the HTTP body; SOAP is transported in the HTTP body,
but its internal structure is defined by the SOAP specification.

WSDL Agreement
SOAP uses a WSDL (Web Services Description Language) file — a contract that the client and server agree upon.

This WSDL defines:

  • The available operations
  • The expected XML structure of each request and response
  • The data types for input and output

Everything is predefined, agreed upon, and non-negotiable.

Strict Validation
SOAP is strict.
If the incoming request does not comply with the expected structure (defined by the WSDL and SOAP spec),
the service fails — typically returning a structured fault message.

Example
Here’s a sample SOAP request for a currency conversion:

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
<soapenv:Envelope xmlns:soapenv="http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/envelope/"
                  xmlns:web="http://www.webserviceX.NET/">
   <soapenv:Header/>
   <soapenv:Body>
      <web:ConversionRate>
         <web:FromCurrency>USD</web:FromCurrency>
         <web:ToCurrency>EUR</web:ToCurrency>
      </web:ConversionRate>
   </soapenv:Body>
</soapenv:Envelope>

The server knows exactly how this should look because it’s defined in the WSDL.

REST: The Architectural Style**

Transport
RESTful services use the HTTP protocol directly, leveraging methods like:

  • GET – retrieve resources
  • POST – create resources
  • PUT – update resources
  • DELETE – remove resources

Why It Is Not a Protocol
REST is not a protocol. It’s an architectural style — a set of principles or constraints, not a rigid specification like SOAP.

REST emphasizes:

  • Statelessness – each request contains all necessary information; no session state is stored on the server
  • Resource-based URLs – operations are performed via HTTP verbs on meaningful URLs
  • Uniform interface – consistent and predictable operations (GET, POST, etc.)

There is no predefined message format or structure.
REST APIs commonly use JSON, but can also use XML, HTML, or plain text.
The structure and content are determined by the developer.


No Pre-Agreement Contracts (By Default)
REST does not require a contract like WSDL.
There is no strict validation of request or response formats.

If a client sends incorrect or incomplete data, the server might respond with:

  • 400 Bad Request
  • 404 Not Found
  • 422 Unprocessable Entity

However, the parsing logic and expected structure are not enforced by a specification — it’s based on mutual understanding between the client and server.


Note:
In REST, API usage and documentation are often described using Swagger/OpenAPI or internal API docs.

These help clients understand:

  • How to send data the server expects
  • How to interpret the response

But this is not validated at runtime — it’s guidance, not a rulebook.


Example

A RESTful API call to get a currency conversion:

1
2
GET /api/convert?from=USD&to=EUR
Host: api.example.com

The response might be:

1
2
3
4
5
{
  "from": "USD",
  "to": "EUR",
  "rate": 0.85
}

Note:
REST can use JSON, XML, or any other text-based format.
It is not tied to any specific data format — it’s simply a conceptual architecture that defines principles for designing networked applications.

The client and server must agree on the format, but there’s no contract enforcing this.

Summary for REST vs SOAP

SOAP

  • Transport:
    Sent over HTTP POST or SMTP

  • Why It Is a Protocol:
    SOAP has a well-defined structure — a SOAP Envelope, which includes:
    • An optional Header (for metadata, authentication, etc.)
    • A mandatory Body containing the operation and data

    Note: This is not the same as the HTTP body — SOAP is transported in the HTTP body, but its internal structure is defined by the SOAP specification.

  • WSDL Agreement:
    The client and server share a WSDL (Web Services Description Language) that defines:
    • What operations exist
    • What XML format each operation must follow
    • What types are expected
  • Strict Validation:
    If the request does not comply with the expected SOAP structure, it fails — typically returning a structured fault message.

REST

  • Transport:
    Sent over HTTP methods (GET, POST, etc.)

  • Why It Is Not a Protocol:
    REST is an architectural style, not a rigid protocol like SOAP.
    It defines principles such as statelessness and resource-based URLs, but does not enforce a strict message format.

  • Message Format:
    Typically uses JSON or XML, but the structure is decided by the developer and not enforced by any specification.

  • No Pre-Agreement Contracts (By Default):
    REST does not require a shared schema or agreement like WSDL.
    The client and server must mutually understand the input and output formats.If the server cannot understand the data (due to wrong format or missing fields), it returns a 4xx error,but no strict parsing rules are enforced.

Note:
In REST, API usage and documentation are typically specified using Swagger, OpenAPI, or other API docs.
These help clients understand how to send information the server expects and how to interpret responses.

However, this is not a form of validation or strict formatting enforcement — it is simply a mutual understanding between the developer and the client.

This post is licensed under CC BY 4.0 by the author.